If everyone is selling in a bear market, does your broker have to buy your shares from you?

Best Answer

jester112358 answered a question in General Market.
411 points

jester112358 answered one year ago …

f everyone is really selling then there is no market and you'll just have to hold your pieces of paper marked "stock" until someone will trade their pieces of paper called "dollars" for them. This situation of no buyers in a market for securities is called a liquidity crisis since no paper asset is really guaranteed to be marketable. This is why everyone is so freaked out about investment banks and banks which hold hundreds of billions in not trillions of dollars of CDOs and SIVS and CDS (all just pieces of paper like your stock, don't worry about what they represent, the bankers certainly didn't when they bought them) for which there is no market. Its like an auction was held and no bidders showed up (this is actually what has been happening in the bond market lately) So, the Fed, read US taxpayers, has recently become the market maker of last resort. We all just trust that a market will exist when we want to sell something, real estate, gold, equities, etc. By the way, this is also true of money market funds which are mostly backed by short term "high quality" corporate debt. Many rating agencies once rated CDOs backed by mortgages as "high quality" too, so "high quality" is in the eye of the beholder.

Sort of scary isn't it? Just like a house of cards which stands up only because we believe it will stand up. So, keep believing investors! If you don't believe then only hold hard assets, such as heating oil, gasoline, food, guns and ammo etc. And by hold I mean store them in your garage with a loaded gun nearby!

Read more from jester112358 great answer



Answers

Oldman answered a question in General Market.
2709 points

Oldman answered one year ago …

Nope - not even if they're your relative and love you.

Read more from Oldman flag as abuse great answer


jillybeansisme answered a question in General Market.
781 points

jillybeansisme answered one year ago …

Your broker is probably selling too! But even if it seems like everyone is selling, somebody will always be buying, probably for value or because they short sold the stock in the first place.

Read more from jillybeansisme flag as abuse great answer


rvilmur answered a question in General Market.
952 points

rvilmur answered one year ago …

Because the stock market is an auction market, for every seller there has to be a buyer. It will not be your broker unless that broker is making a market in that stock being sold.

So, in a severe down market, sales occur only a price that finds a buyer. That is why there are opening gaps in prices on overnite news.

Read more from rvilmur flag as abuse great answer