What do you think of sector funds? I'm not much in favor, but wonder if there are more advantages than I see.

Some people seem to believe that they are safer or more stable than individual equities, but how do they differ from an index fund? Is it possible for them to do better than average?

Best Answer

thinker70 answered a question in General Market.
731 points

thinker70 answered 11 months ago …

The key to success as an investor is similar to Waynes Gretzkys comment in respect to being a good hockey player who ANTICIPATES the play by skating to where the puck is GOING TO BE NEXT, not where it is now.

The market is forward looking to a degree but an investor to be successful has to get there before the herd! In other words read widely, have good basic common sense to relate facts and trends to anticipate what the market is likely to do in the future.

This is where ETF's are miles ahead of mutual funds because of lower management fees, greater flexibility, ease of getting in and out etc. You still have to choose wisely, but they allow you to narrow your target!

For example; I just read a piece by Jay Taylor who made the point that the DEMAND for gold coins and ingots has been red hot lately, while production from mines has been DECLINING! Add to that a serious decline in PRODUCTION costs with the drop in the oil price, plus base metals prices being so low some mines are closing, (temporarily until prices improve) resulting in EXPERIENCED geologists and minors etc. looking for jobs.

Combine all those facts and what do you have, a good case for gold and silver miners future prospects? The choice then becomes 1) do you buy a couple leading gold miners like Barrick, Newmont, Kinross, Yamana etc. or 2) do you bet on emerging producers whose reserves have not YET been recognized by the mainstream and so are grossly undervalued, or 3) do you simply buy an ETF like the Market Vectors Gold Miners Trust that invests in a wide range of producers? I use this example to illustrate the points I nade initially, only the individual investor can make the choice most appropriate for his personal portfolio allocation!

Read more from thinker70



Answers

sihowe answered a question in General Market.
142 points

sihowe answered 11 months ago …

Sector funds are great if you do not wish to expose yourself to asset-specific risk that comes with buying individual stocks.

To answer your question about being safer or more stable - no investment/trade is really safer or more stable than another one without you doing due diligence. But if what you're asking is if sector funds inherently have less risk than individual stocks, then the answer is yes.

As to how they differ from index funds, index funds normally track a market index average like the S&P500 or the Russell 2000. Sector funds are more specialized in the sense that they track various industries, e.g. technology, retail etc. To see an example of this, just google SPDRs. These funds track 9 S&P sectors.

Sector funds most definitely can do better than average, only if you select the proper ones. In every market cycle, there will be sectors that lead the market, and sectors that lag the market. Put your money in those outperforming sectors and you should beat the market averages quite nicely.

Read more from sihowe


MNSL answered a question in General Market.
3963 points

MNSL answered 11 months ago …

Definitely some sectors will outperform the market.

This is the time to change out etfs, sectors, top investment banks, banks, insurance and retirement providers, etc. Otherwise some times we will lose our entire money in the next 10 years.

Read more from MNSL


MNSL answered a question in General Market.
3963 points

MNSL answered 11 months ago …

Not all the ETFs will outperform market in the next 06 months, next 18 months and next 05 years. We have to be very careful in selecting ETFS now. There are few sectors definitely will benefit from current mess. Some ETFs will benefit in the long run.

Some ETFS will liquidate sooner than later.

http://finance.yahoo.com/news/HealthShares-Throws-In-Towel-indexuniverse-1 3710948.html

HealthShares is going to liquidate its four exchange-traded funds and dissolve the HealthShares fund management company on Dec. 31. They just weren't healthy investments.

I think it is time to avoid ETFS in hot sectors

Read more from MNSL