Are annuities a good way to preserve my principle while getting a decent return?

Answers

readytoretire answered a question in General Market.
2222 points

readytoretire answered 9 months ago …

This investment is like most of them, it depends. An annuity is normally issued by an insurance company, for example, and offers the investor a portion of the income that the insurance company expects to make from having your money for a time period. I would be surprised if the return being offered in these days was much, more likely is that most is a 'guarantee' of return of principle. Another way to look at it is as a CD with different payout options. Another way to tell how good a deal it is for the investor is to see how much the person selling it makes on commission, the more, normally the worse it is as far as a actual return.

Read more from readytoretire


Oldman answered a question in General Market.
2775 points

Oldman answered 8 months ago …

ReadytoRetire's answer is really good, if you already understand how annuities are structured. One can purchase a fixed annuity = constant monthly payments for your life, or for joint and survivor, or for certain definite periods (if you die before the payments would stop, say after 5 years but before 10 years from the time the payments begin, then a beneficiary will get the remainder either in payments as you did or in a discounted lump-sum). One can add all sorts of bells and whistles, e.g., a guarantee of a remainder payment if you die sooner than the insurance company's calculation of the "avg. lifespan".

There's a site on the web;

http//:www.immediateannuities.com.

which will allow you to a- play around with the need for a monthly income, or an initial payment or what would be the monthly decrease in payments for the variety of options.

Next, we get to "variable annuities" which are designed to make lots of fees for the producers and salespeople. I detest them.

In a tax-sheltered account: You could just purchase some laddered C.D.'s (5 yr term and a portion of the remainder of the first discounted 10K could be put into a world or US stock index...No big fees, no surrender charges if you want to terminate the investment schema early...variable and fixed annuities may offer high "Tease" rates, but there are surrender charges that decrease from 7 % to zero over 7 years from the first step of the investment...and you are unlikely to beat a CD/stock index fund's returns...and you can purchase this in an IRA. One year, in the IRA you could start with a purchase of a 5-yr CD, the next with a purchase of a "TIP" ETF (Treasury-Inflation-Protected bonds that garuantee your bond will be redeemed for a minimum of face---or inflation-adjusted value).

The next thing about any annuiies, is that the older you are when payment begins, the higher the payout (they don't expect you to live > avg.)

The next thing about annuiies, is that they're only as secure as the Insurance company's funding of the separate accounts, to cover the projected (contractual) income stream. Most annuities are only federally insured to a certain maximum, which I believe is $100K in principal, but it might be more.

By the way, Social Security payments are the best annuity one can get, because they're partially indexed for inflation...and the payments don't decrease due to deflation.

Finally, if you do purchase an annuity and after a few years it looks to be a bummer...you can do a Section 1035 (Tax-Exempt) exchange, but you'll still get hit with some fees and surrender charges.

Read more from Oldman


Oldman answered a question in General Market.
2775 points

Oldman answered 8 months ago …

P.S.

A question by Meljones a week ago also touched on this topic---with equity-indexed variable annuities.

I gave an example of a discounted 10 yr run in the answer.

Read more from Oldman